Defying Gravity: The Best Eye Primers for Mature Skin

Do you ever stare at yourself in the mirror and lament about the youthful, vibrant skin you once had? Are you noticing discoloration, undereye bags, fine lines, and wrinkles growing and deepening by the day? Have you invested more in cosmetics and skincare products than you care to admit?

If so, you aren't alone. According to an estimation from cosmetic specialists' published research, the average American woman will spend $15,000 over her lifetime to look younger.

Excusing your worsening undereye concerns by chocking it all up to gravity and mother nature isn't going to make you feel any better about them. You'll still want to wish them good riddance — as many women do. 

However, a suitable undereye primer can change everything. Discover the beauty in the best eye primers for mature skin and the magic you'll experience with the skin-loving nourishment your eyelids and undereye areas crave with a primer.

This article offers the best eye and face primer duos, trios, and treatments to have your eyes glistening and sparkling again. These top picks of 2022 for the best eye primers for mature skin with a complete guide to why women all encounter aging eyes. Take back your youthful skin now!

In a Nutshell: The Science Behind Tired Eyes 

To start, we need to understand why and how your eyes seem to give in to the pulls of gravity, Mother Nature, and exhaustion. If you look sleepy to others, you may well be sleep deprived. A published study of 2000 Americans showed that middle-aged women suffer more fatigue than men.

However, fine and coarse wrinkles, hyperpigmentation, inflamed eyelids, undereye bags with redness, and facial laxity are caused by more than just sleep quality. Skin changes due to weakening eyelid muscles, collagen enzyme loss, and unrestricted blood vessels forming undereye bags and dark circles. Additional environmental stressors will dull, dehydrate, and damage skin, adding to signs of aging — especially on your face. 

If you are experiencing these changes, don't fret! Keep reading for some solutions to these issues.woman putting serum on face

Reducing Harm and Repairing Skin: Collagen, Caffeine, Self-Care & Eye Primer

If you are serious about reducing the harm done to your mature skin, you first need to know that your skin requires two sources of hydration to keep its plump and healthy appearance: internal and external hydration.

Internal sources for quenched skin include regular water intake and a diet limited in or free of fried and excessively salty food. Eat hydrating fruits like grapes and melons. Cruciferous veggies are an excellent source of antioxidants and vitamins for your skin health

External sources include moisturizers, sheet masks, serums, and hyaluronic acid to lock the moisture in.

You can try using ice packs first thing in the morning to restrict the lax blood vessels around your eyes. Add supplements and vitamins A, B6, 12, C, D, E, and K, as well as high-quality collagen powders or coffee drink mix to get ahead of the game. Caffeine and Omega 3s are also necessary to rescue your skin, along with a good workout to get your blood pumping before you start your beauty routine. Besides, exercise is a proven mood booster, and who doesn't want that?

The Magic of Eye Primer for Mature Skin: Eyelid & Undereye A+ Treatments

It's safe to assume that most women don't even think eye primer is necessary. However, if you feel your skin is aging faster by the day, you will want to see this. 

Before digging too far into this topic, it is important to understand the difference between a face or foundation primer and an eye primer. A face primer has different effects than a primer for your eyes, and they should not be interchangeably used. Using foundation primer on your eyelids or under the eyes will wreak havoc on your eye makeup's staying power. Most face primers even warn users not to apply it on or around the eyes on the label. 

Some eye primers are solely made to lock eyeshadow into place and blur creases. Then there are eye primers which are more helpful with issues like discoloration, coarse wrinkles, droopy eyelids, and undereye bags or puffiness. A quality eye primer will beautifully camouflage your fine lines and discoloration while treating your eyelids to all the best nutrients it offers. 

Now, it's time to discover your particular type of priming magic. Get ready to kick your feet up and be amazed at these findings.

The Eyes Made to Envy: The Age-Defying Special Edit of the Best Eye Primers for Mature Skin

It's time to detail the best-of-the-best eye primers for mature skin.

Whether you're dealing with oily eyelids or sensitive skin, you can call off the search for help because this guide considers all skin types, tones, and concerns to come up with the most effective and potent concoctions of cosmeceutical elixirs.

This is your complete guide to primer duos, trios, and invaluable creams and treatments to precede makeup applications for magical age-proof results.

Eyeshadow Primer Potion: Anti-Aging
$27.00 ($81.82 / Fl Oz)

by Urban Decay 

Buy Now on Amazon Buy Now on Sephora
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/20/2023 08:09 pm GMT

Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potion: Anti-Aging

Urban Decay is a cosmetic brand under the parent company L'oreal Paris™, and its eyeshadow primers boast all-day wear with no creasing of the lids. Urban Decay has four eye primers — Eden, Sin, Original, and Anti-Aging — and when using this product, a little goes a long way.

Many users agree that the Urban Decay Eyeshadow Primer Potions are the best sheer crease camouflaging magicians available. If you need help with discoloration, though, the sheerness of the Primer may be more of a detriment than a benefit.

Why You'll Love This Primer

This primer is suitable for all skin types, tones, and textures. Those with sensitive skin can even wear this primer and slay all day in it. The vegan clean company doesn't use any parabens or sulfate and includes a flocked wand applicator.

Urban Decay Potion Specs

Weight of Product: 0.33 Fl Oz Form: Cream Suitable Skin Types: All Specialty: Oily control, crepey lid camo Clean: Yes, vegan clean

Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eye Primer
$28.55 ($161.85 / Ounce)

by MAC 

Buy Now on Amazon Buy Now on Ulta
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/20/2023 08:18 pm GMT

MAC Pro Longwear Paint Pot Eye Primer – Princess Cut and Bougie

MAC is an acronym for Makeup Art Cosmetics and was founded by two photographers in Toronto, Canada, because of their frustration that the makeup of the day didn't photograph well. Now, MAC is an official makeup brand that caters to movie stars. You may have heard of the Ruby Woo lipstick or the StudioFix makeup line, but do you know that they are owned by none other than Estee Lauder™?

Why You'll Love This Primer

Other than the rich, vibrant hues of the cream primer/eyeshadow all-in-one, this eye primer is non-flaking, caking, or creasing; it's non-acnegenic, smudge-proof, and has a stays-put, stay-true color for 24 hours. The formulas for each water-resistant color are dermatologist and ophthalmologist-tested and approved.

The primer comes in a wide array of colors to dress your eyes, like a smoothing, opaque shimmering pink "Princess Cut" paint pot or "Bougie" bold brick red with overlays of green shimmer. This eye primer is for the upper and the under eyelid to camouflage any bags, discoloration, and fine or coarse, crepey lines.

MAC Paint Pot Specs

Weight of Product (ea.): 5G/0.17 Fl Oz Form: Cream-to-powder Suitable Skin Types: All Specialty: Crepey discolored eyelids, undereye bag camouflage, Longwear, Vibrant Color Clean: Sulfate, Paraben, and Mineral Oil-Free, No Animal Testing, No Formaldehyde

Favorite Priming Duos and Trios to Get It Right Every Time

Here at Age Defying, the goal is to go above and beyond by giving you more than the bare minimum. Next, you'll learn about some powerful priming duos and trios of solid, science-backed makeup and skincare for your best skin EVER! These sets of magic will likely have you looking like you're 25 again if you let them.

Hydragel Lift Plumping Moisturizer

by PUR 

Buy Now on Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.

PUR Hydragel Lift & Get A Lift Plumping Moisturizer: The Best Under Eye Hydrating Primer   

The name of this beauty line says it all! The PUR brand is determined to make all hypoallergenic products and offer super hydration to your face with all-natural, gentle, yet powerful ingredients to help you reclaim your youth!

The PUR Hydragel Lift uses encapsulated water to super-punch your skin with lasting hydration from pure water straight off the Swiss Alps. PUR gives your eyelids the benefits of a whole host of natural blurring and perfecting ingredients, renewing your skin with lasting results after the makeup is washed off. The Get a Lift cream moisturizer is non-comedogenic and works to shrink your pores to improve the texture of your face.

Both products work together like a dream to plump your skin to smooth wrinkles, discoloration, bags under the eyes, and crepey skin and gradually work to diminish signs of aging with regular use.

Thank Me Later Eye Primer & Perfecting Face Primer

by Elizabeth Mott’s 

Buy Now on Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/20/2023 08:22 pm GMT

Elizabeth Mott's Thank Me Later Eye Primer & Perfecting Face Primer: Best All-Around Eye Primer for Mature Skin

This primer duo is a true fan favorite for its effective, long-lasting hydration and skin-blurring abilities. Elizabeth Mott's eye primer provides non-greasy moisture to brighten your lids while combating oil and creasing with this mattifying formula. You can lock your eye makeup into place with its incredible stay-all-day grip. The foundation primer is equally amazing, with a brightening and balancing mattifying primer.

Thank Me Later (TML) is perfect for correcting dull, uneven skin tones and shrinking enlarged pores to give you a flawless makeup look that lasts from morning to night. While the TML primers are for oily skin, they are suitable for all types.

Eye Lift 360º Brilliant Eye Brightener & Blurring Face Primer
$35.02 ($129.70 / Fl Oz)

by Thrive Causemetics 

Buy Now on Amazon
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/20/2023 08:29 pm GMT

Thrive Causemetics Eye Lift 360º, Brilliant Eye Brightener & Blurring Face Primer: The Best for Dry Mature Skin

The Eye Lift 360º Waterproof Eye Primer™ is made with Thrive's own Eye Revive Complex™ which powers up your natural collagen and elastin production to revitalize the skin surrounding the eye for a bright, crease-free look. This trio of skin rescuers is made to suit every skin type, tone, and texture.

The Brilliant Eye Brightener is perfect to use under the eye and on the lids to conceal and brighten discoloration and dullness before the primers. The shade "Stella" is a buildable shimmery gold tube of skin-perfecting color.Thrive Causemetics Brilliant Eye Brightener

The Blurring Face Primer from Eye Lift 360º is an oil-free mattifying magician that offers a load of skin benefits beneath its surface as well as on top. Because of its Color Grip Technology™, your makeup will be secured to your skin with no smudging or budging all day. The powerful face primer is suitable to use on or below the eyes because of its 360º sensitivity safe formula. Get ready to see your pores, skin's texture, and fine lines transformed instantly, but also over time. Use this primer with the brand's Buildable Blur™ CC Cream BS SPF 40 for immaculate results.

 Filtered Effects™ Blurring Primer

"Drug Store" Duos You've Got to Try

If you just can't justify the prices of designer brands, look here for the "Best Eye Primer for Mature Skin: Drugstore Edition"! It's fun to find the cheapest yet most effective options. Drugstore cosmetics have a bad reputation, but "cheap" doesn't mean less effective by any stretch of the imagination! Here are our top picks for the best drugstore under-eye and eyelid primer duos.

PhotoReady Eye Primer & Brightener

by Revlon 

Buy Now on Amazon Buy Now on CVS
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/20/2023 08:29 pm GMT

Face Gloss (Primer) Rose Glow

by PhotoReady 

Buy Now on Amazon Buy Now on CVS
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/20/2023 08:41 pm GMT

Revlon PhotoReady Eye Primer & Brightener & PhotoReady Face Gloss (Primer) Rose Glow

The PhotoReady Eye Primer, Brightener, and Face Gloss seamlessly work together to smooth, perfect, and brighten your skin all day and night! The eye primer brightening pen puts you in control of each dose of this perfecting formula. You'll get a creaseless, even tone on your lids and expertly concealed dark spots underneath every time.

The Face Gloss Rose Glow offers you a plump, hydrated and illuminated look with the infusion of a superfruit glycerin complex, olive oil extract, and 80% water. You can use the Face Gloss alone, under makeup, or over your cheekbones to achieve a dewy, youthful, and iridescent glow.

Color Stay 24-Hour Eyeshadow Primer

by Revlon 

Buy Now on Amazon Buy Now on CVS
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/20/2023 08:42 pm GMT

Color Stay Grip 24-Hour Face Primer

by Revlon

Buy Now on Amazon Buy Now on CVS
We earn a commission if you make a purchase, at no additional cost to you.
09/20/2023 08:47 pm GMT

Revlon Color Stay 24-Hour Eyeshadow Primer & Color Stay Grip 24-Hour Face Primer

Revlon made the cut twice, and with good reason: Its efficacy! The 24-Hour Eyeshadow and Face Primer duo is a fantastic long-lasting, non-drying formula infused with a shea butter complex. Get your creaseless, non-greasy eye perfection on and leave it on into the wee hours of tomorrow. The smoothing eyeshadow primer will easily facilitate any everyday looks and the boldest faces.

The Color Stay Prep & Protect Face Primer has a grip that won't let your makeup smudge, budge, or fade for at least 24 hours! Revlon's long-wear formula absorbs oil while hydrating your skin for a flawless, matte look. Protection is built in from everyday environmental stressors with an SPF 34 that really delivers.

Under Eye Treatments That Can Change Your Life

Before signing off, here are a couple options to ensure you're covered with the best treatments to use with the preceding products. Feel free to use any combination of the products in this expertly curated "Best Eye Primers for Mature Skin" list, or as stand-alone skin therapy. 

First, there's  IT Cosmetics' Bye-Bye Undereye cream and the corresponding concealer for effective beneath-the-skin reparation and illumination atop the eyes.

Second, the Pacifica Dreamlit Glow Undereye Brightener and the vegan collagen Hydro-Treatment for Undereye and Smile Lines. This pair is all you'll need to feel good and look it too. Pacifica uses real science-in-action to literally save your face!

The final recommendation is TULA's Glow and Get It Cooling and Brightening Undereye Balm for relieving and treating puffy, dark circles that won't quit. It will force the resignation of those eyebags within minutes!woman putting on eye primer

Mature Skin is Just Skin That Needs a Little TLC

Everyone can be proactive when it comes to skincare. Any of the eye primers and primer duos in this guide are clean, suitable for all skin types, and guaranteed to be the ultimate skincare on the market! Discover your best eye primers for maturing and mature skin and rest on the science behind these top picks. You can feel as good about your makeup as your skincare!

Was this article helpful?